
introduction
Lesson 8: Legal Issues
Among others of a number of reform movements of the past 25 years,
restorative justice grew out of the informal justice movement, the
victim rights movement and the restitution/diversion movement (designed
to alleviate the burden put on the judicial system by increasingly
incarcerative responses to crime). As its antecedents did, restorative
justice has raised several legal issues related to its implementation
as a system of criminal justice. Among these are jurisprudential
concerns, victims' and offenders' rights, and procedural issues. More
specifically, in this section:
- due
process deals with the procedural protections traditionally
accorded offenders, and the extent to which restorative processes
provide those protections--
- presumption of innocence assesses the restorative justice system's ability to preserve the presumption that the person is innocent, unless, and until, the person's guilt is proven;
- the right to a fair trial/coercion explores the degree to which the offender retains the right to a formal trial in a restorative justice system, and the extent to which the coercive forces of such a system would be so overwhelming as to essentially compel the offender to take part in a restorative process;
- the right to assistance of counsel deals with the question of what
role attorneys play in a restorative process, and the offender's
ability to safeguard his rights vis a vis assistance of legal
counsel;
- e qual protection/discrimination describes the potential for the restorative justice system to even-handedly administer justice without regard to race, gender, religion, national origin, social standing, etc., and raises as a concern the inequities that could exist based on these and other factors;
- victims' rights discusses the assertion (and its equal protection implications) that victims are interested parties who should have standing and should be granted rights accordingly; and
- proportionality examines the goal for the traditional system in which similar offenses result in similar outcomes to satisfy a sense of fairness, and the notions of fairness within a restorative system which are based on consensus of agreement given a range of alternatives--e.g., participant satisfaction.
Document Actions
Last modified Jun 22, 2005 03:12 AM
